Skip to content
There are many things to consider when you’re deciding on the overall look of your kitchen, and one of the most essential is painted vs. stained cabinets. Neither is necessarily better or worse than the other – it just depends on your particular needs, preferences, and the rest of the décor in the room in question.
Both painted and stained cabinets offer distinct advantages and potential disadvantages in terms of aesthetics and functionality too.
Painted cabinets tend to provide a sleek, uniform appearance that will complement a plethora of modern and contemporary designs. When the cabinet is painted, it’s easier to have precise control over the overall finish of the entire piece of furniture.
Stained cabinets tend to focus on highlighting the natural beauty of the wood. This helps add warmth and character to kitchens that are more traditional or rustic. Using a stain on a cabinet, however, leads to less consistency in the overall finish, compared to painted cabinets.
In this article, we’ll explore exactly what painted and stained cabinets are, followed by specific features of the finish and some things to take into consideration. Then, we’ll do a direct comparison of the two so that you’ll be fully informed and ready to make a decision when furnishing your home.
Painted Cabinets
A painted cabinet is a cabinet that has a solid layer of paint applied to its surface, covering all the natural grain of the wood. The result is a uniform, smooth finish that can be in any color you choose, whether you’re into neutral shades like whites or grays, or vibrant colors like yellow or blue.
Key Features of Painted Cabinets
Here are some key features of painted cabinets:
- Smooth, Uniform Finish: They tend to have a sleek look since the grain of the wood isn’t visible at all. This tends to be ideal if you’re going for a modern, contemporary look.
- Consistent Color: When painted, it’s possible to have a consistent color throughout the piece of furniture.
Versatile Color Options: You can choose from any color in the rainbow, whether you want a neutral or more natural look, or bright, eye-catching colors.
- Easy to Clean: The surface of the wood is smooth and non-porous, so it’s easy to clean and maintain. Spills and stains can be wiped right off without any fuss.
- Customizable: Since you can choose any color you like, there’s a lot of potential for customization.
- Covering Faults/Imperfections: You can use paint to cover up inconsistencies in the wood or imperfections.
Considerations When Choosing Painted Cabinets
Just like anything, there are always things to consider when you choose to go with a painted cabinet rather than a stained finish. They’re not always cons; it just depends on your preferences and what you’re looking for.
Here are a few things to bear in mind when considering painted cabinets:
- More Likely to Chip: Since paint only covers the surface of the wood, it’s more likely to chip than if you go for a stain. You can use topcoats and varnishes, but it’s something to remember if it’s a high-use cabinet, since you may end up needing to do regular touch ups.
- Sensitivity to Moisture: Painted cabinets can be more sensitive to moisture. This can result in the paint swelling or peeling if it’s exposed to water or high humidity.
- Covers the Natural Beauty of the Wood: Remember that paint will completely cover the natural beauty of the wood. So, if you’re trying to do this and cover imperfections, this is a great option. But if you’re working with a high-quality piece of wood, you may want to reconsider staining it.
- Requires More Maintenance: Paint tends to require more maintenance since it’s striving for a smooth, uniform appearance, so any scratches, chips or blemishes will detract from the look.
Stained Cabinets
A stained cabinet is one that has had a stain applied to the surface of the wood. Now, a stain doesn’t cover the surface, it actually enhances and highlights the natural grain and texture. If you like variation, you can choose between a range of shades, whether you want a light or a dark stain.
Key Features of Stained Cabinets
Here are some key features of stained cabinets:
- Enhances Natural Beauty: A stain is the ideal finish to choose if you’d like to enhance the natural beauty of the wood grain. It offers an organic, warm look that adds character to the room.
- Natural Patterns: Different types of wood boast their own natural pattern, so when you use a stain, you’re embracing the uniqueness of your piece of furniture.
- Resistant to Chipping and Wear and Tear: The stain actually penetrates the wood, so it’s a bit stronger. This also means that it’s less prone to chipping compared to painted surfaces, and scratches and dents are also less noticeable.
- Timeless Aesthetic: A wood stain tends to offer a timeless, classic look, making it ideal for a traditional, transitional, or rustic décor.
- Warm and Rich Tones: A wood stain enhances the natural color of the wood, so they tend to result in warm, rich colors.
Things to Consider When Choosing Stained Cabinets
- Limited Color Options: Wood stains enhance the natural color of the wood, so you can only really go darker or lighter than the original color.
- More Difficult to Clean: Since you’re dealing with a porous surface, it can be more difficult or time consuming to clean a stained wooden cabinet.
- Wood Quality: A stain will highlight every feature of the wood that’s used, so it’s imperative that the cabinet is made from a high-quality, attractive piece of wood.
- Maintenance: The stain won’t chip like paint will, but it’s still important that the surface is maintained regularly – this may require regular re-sealing.
Painted Vs. Stained Cabinets: How to Make the Decision
Some of the key features of each type of cabinet have to do with what you’re willing to do in terms of maintenance, the aesthetic you’re looking for, and the type of wood you’re working with.
If you have a high-quality piece of wood, a stain would probably be the best bet for you. If you want to cover up certain parts of the wood, then paint is probably what you’re looking for. Furthermore, with a stain, you have fewer options in terms of outward appearance, whereas if you use paint, you can pick any color you like.
So, when you’re considering painted vs. stained cabinets, take a moment to consider your preferences and what you’re working with before you make this decision. If you aren't sure, contact Amishwerks and we'll be happy to help!